Prince (November 9, 1981) “Prince fails to make delivery on promises” – The Beaumont Enterprise

A mixed-to-negative review in The Beaumont Enterprise (Knight-Ridder Service) by Rick Shefchik of Prince’s 1981 album Controversy, acknowledging strong moments but criticizing it for failing to fully deliver on the promise shown in Dirty Mind, particularly due to uneven material and overly explicit content.

Publication: The Beaumont Enterprise Date: Monday, November 9, 1981 Country: United States Section / Pages: Records / Album Reviews Title: Prince fails to make delivery on promises

THE STORY

Reviewer Rick Shefchik expresses disappointment after high anticipation for Prince’s follow-up to Dirty Mind. He praises Side Two tracks like “Private Joy,” “Ronnie Talk to Russia,” and “Annie Christian” for their energy and craft, but finds much of Side One lacking imagination. The closing song is called a “smutty, strutting rockabilly shuffle” unsuitable for radio. Overall, he concludes that Prince “hasn’t delivered on the promise yet.”

CONTEXT AND NOTES

This review appeared almost exactly one year after the Dirty Mind coverage, during the Controversy album cycle (released October 1981). It reflects the pressure on Prince to follow up his breakthrough with something even stronger, a common theme in early critical responses to his rapid output.

EATURE HIGHLIGHTS

Event: Album review of Controversy (Warner Bros.) Era: Controversy era (1981) Tone: Disappointed, critical of unevenness and explicitness Photography: None (text review)

Visual Motifs: Standard syndicated newspaper album review column

WHAT THE CLIPPING SHOWS

• Critical skepticism toward Prince’s 1981 follow-up

• Acknowledgment of his talent and promise alongside frustration with execution

• Period-typical focus on radio-friendliness and lyrical controversy

• 
  

RELATED MATERIAL

For other relevant posts, see the tags at the foot of the page.

All magazine scans, photographs and original text excerpts remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference.

Dirty Mind is Prince’s third studio album, released in October 1980. A daring, raw, and sexually explicit masterpiece, it marked a bold artistic leap and established Prince as one of the most provocative and innovative artists of his generation.

RELEASE DETAILS

Artist: Prince

Label: Warner Bros. Records

Date: October 8, 1980

Catalogue: BSK 3478

Format: LP

Country: United States (international releases followed)

THE STORY

Dirty Mind is a short, explosive album that fully embraces funk, new wave, and rock influences. Recorded quickly at his home studio in Orono, Minnesota (credited as “Somewhere in Uptown”), the album features Prince playing nearly all instruments himself. The songs are direct, explicit, and full of attitude, tackling themes of sex, freedom, and rebellion with a punk-like energy.

CONTEXT & NOTES

Coming less than a year after his previous album, Dirty Mind shocked many with its explicit content and minimalist sound. Though it received mixed commercial response at the time, it is now regarded as one of Prince’s most important and influential records, laying the groundwork for his revolutionary 1980s output.

TRACK LIST

Side One

Dirty Mind (4:11)

When You Were Mine (3:44)

Do It All Night (3:42)

Gotta Broken Heart Again (2:13)

Side Two

Uptown (5:30)

Head (4:40)

Sister (1:33)

Partyup (4:24)

PERSONNEL

Musicians

• Prince — all vocals and instruments (except where noted)

• Dr. Fink — synthesizer on “Dirty Mind” and “Head”

• Lisa Coleman — vocals on “Head”, keyboards and background vocals on “Partyup” (uncredited)

Production

• Prince — producer, arranger, remixer

• Jamie Starr — engineer (Prince pseudonym)

• Mic Guzauski — remixer

• Bob Mockler — remixer

• Ron Garrett — assistant

• Bernie Grundman — mastering (A&M Records)

• Allen Beaulieu — photography

• Bob Cavallo, Joe Ruffalo, Steve Fargnoli — personal management

Special Thanks "Special thanks to God, Jamie and Steve, Fink, Bobby Z., Andre, Dez, Lisa, Gayle, Russ Thyret, Mo Ostin, Tom Draper, Cortez T. and the 'baddest promotion staff around'; Fred Moultrie, Lee Phillips, Bob and Joe, Cynthia Horner, Kim, Nick, Debbie Dominico, Rob Marcher, Fred Lapin, Dave, Chip, Paul and Steve M., Mena, Joni and U."

PACKAGING HIGHLIGHTS

• Iconic black-and-white cover photo of Prince in a trench coat and bandana

• Minimalist design with bold pink lettering

• Striking and controversial visual identity

• 
  

WHAT THE SLEEVE SHOWS

 The front cover shows a bare-chested Prince wearing an open trench coat, bandana, and dark underwear, staring directly at the camera with a provocative expression. The bold pink “Prince” logo dominates the top. The image perfectly captured the album’s raw, rebellious, and sexually charged attitude.

CHARTS America

Country: Chart | Entry Date | Peak Position | Weeks in Chart

USA: Billboard Top LP’s & Tapes | 8 Nov. 1980 | 45 | 31

USA: Billboard Soul LPs | 8 Nov. 1980 | 7 | 32

USA: The Billboard 200 | 14 May 2016 | 56 (R) | 2

SINGLES RELEASED

• “Uptown” (b/w “Crazy You”)

• “Dirty Mind” (b/w “When We’re Dancing Close and Slow”)

• “Do It All Night” (UK only)

• “Head” (promo only)

• “When You Were Mine” (12" promo only)

Dirty Mind received widespread praise from critics. Simon Reynolds noted its rave reception, with rock writers hailing Prince as a genre-blending, gender-bending, and race-bridging savior of modern music. Barney Hoskyns called it “the glam-funk Let’s Get It On” in his New Musical Express review. Ken Tucker of Rolling Stone observed Prince’s shift from the romantic tone of his earlier albums to a liberating lewdness, mixing provocative wordplay with simple, catchy melodies over an electric sound. He praised Prince’s effortless delivery, blending Smokey Robinson’s sweetness with Richard Pryor’s raw humor, calling the record “cool music dealing with hot emotions” and, at its best, “positively filthy.” In The Village Voice, Robert Christgau compared the metallic textures and drum patterns to Funkadelic and the Rolling Stones, noting Prince’s falsetto linked him to the “love-man” tradition but with a bolder eroticism. Retrospective reviews, like Jim Green’s in The Trouser Press Guide to New Wave Records, also celebrated the album’s catchy tunes, witty lyrics, strong production, and Prince’s signature falsetto—provided the overt sexuality doesn’t turn listeners away.

SOURCES Prince Vault, The Beautiful Ones (2019), Discogs, Warner Bros. archives.

COPYRIGHT NOTICE All album artwork, photographs, logos, and original text excerpts remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference.